NIH Extramural Center Programs: Criteria for Initiation and Evaluation

Grants for research centers located in universities, medical centers, and other nonprofit research institutions account for about 9 percent of the National Institutes of Health budget. Centers are popular because they can bring visibility, focus, and increased resources to bear on specific diseases. However, congressional debate in 2001 over proposed legislation directing NIH to set up centers for muscular dystrophy research highlighted several areas of uncertainty about how to decide when centers are an appropriate research mechanism in specific cases. The debate also highlighted a growing trend among patient advocacy groups to regard centers as a key element of every disease research program, regardless of how much is known about the disease in question, the availability of experienced researchers, and other factors. This book examines the criteria and procedures used in deciding whether to establish new specialized research centers. It discusses the future role of centers in light of the growing trend of large-scale research in biomedicine, and it offers recommendations for improving the classification and tracking of center programs, clarifying and improving the decision process and criteria for initiating center programs, resolving the occasional disagreements over the appropriateness of centers, and evaluating the performance of center programs more regularly and systematically. Table of ContentsFront MatterExecutive Summary1 Introduction2 Current Use of Center Awards3 Initiation and Management of Center Programs4 Criteria for Establishing Center Programs5 Evaluation of Center Programs6 Closing Comments and Thoughts About the FutureAppendix A: NIH Centers ProgramsAppendix B: Biographical Sketches of Committee and StaffAppendix C: NIH Research Award Activity Codes and Their DefinitionsAppendix D: NIH Program Planning ProcessAppendix E: Justification for Center Programs Used in Recent RFAs and PAsAppendix F: Summaries of NIH Selected Center Program Evaluations Previously Conducted by NIH